Skip to content
evolve.tt

Thinking

Use the Model as a Sparring Partner

State a claim, ask for the strongest objection, and answer that objection yourself. Agreement from the model is not evidence.

The useful move is not to ask the tool what you think. You already have a view, or you do not have a session yet. The tool’s job, if it has one, is to make that view harder to hold. You decide whether it survives.

Your claim, then the strongest objection, then your reply.
Infographic You answer the objection. The model does not. Drawn for evolve.tt.
  1. Your claim

    One sentence, in your words.

  2. The objection

    Ask for the strongest one, not for agreement.

  3. Your reply

    You write it. If you cannot, the claim is not ready.

One round

One round, on a claim this site already answers

Section titled “One round, on a claim this site already answers”

Claim: “50 percent is a CSEC pass.”

Ask for the strongest objection. The one worth hearing is the one in a class test is not a CSEC grade: CXC reports grades, and grades I, II, and III are the grades treated as passes. A percentage is a different scale.

If the tool agrees that 50 percent is a pass, the sparring failed. It took your side. You still have to open a page that states the grades, or ask your teacher to show you that page. Checking an answer is that step. A second chatbot that votes with the first is not.

Your reply, if you can make it, is short. “A class test out of 100 is not a CSEC result. Grade I is the highest grade, then II, then III.” If you cannot say that with the chat closed, you did not spar. You collected a sentence.

A price, a dose, a law, or today’s materials cost. Those need a source you open, not a more elegant argument. Do not paste anyone’s private details in order to have the argument. The shape of the claim is enough.

Write the objection you can already make before you open the chat. Otherwise you will not know which half of the round was yours.

Try it

One round, in your words

Nothing here is sent. Closing the page clears it. The model is not in this round.

Discussion

View all discussions on GitHub